Struggling businesses in Donegal could turn their fortunes around by following the example of the Donegal Football team and learning from how it has been transformed over the past two seasons according to a Donegal businessman based in Hong Kong.
Ray Porter from Raphoe who has held senior positions multi-national giants Intel and Dell and spent a number of years providing consulting services to a wide range of industries, is currently based in Hong Kong where he is Director of operations for Irish company PCH International.
In this article he discusses how the approach Jim McGuinness has taken to transform Donegal football bears similarities to the approach a business could take on its own transformation journey.
Engage an expert
If you looked in business terms at the Donegal team in 2010 after that defeat against Armagh, they were like a going concern. If you considered the supporters as shareholders you’d be saying they were pretty unhappy – and yet look how things have changed in a short time.
In business if you want to drive any significant change it is import to appoint a leader that understands the type and depth of change required and has the desire to drive the change to its end state.
For Donegal, Jim McGuinness fitted the leadership requirements at many levels. As a player he’s pretty much won it all and his background as a fitness coach and in sports psychology was and added advantage. It is often said in business “you can’t improve something if you don’t understand it.” Jim McGuinness certainly understands Gaelic football – every successful business needs a Jim McGuinness in their ranks – or access to one.
Have the “End in mind”
Many people enter in to business with a “good idea” but fall into a trap of just working away from day to day or week to week making some progress and trying to getting over each bump on the road as it appears.
This approach may work in the short term but inevitably there will a bump on the road that might too hard to get over. If you start off with the “End in Mind,” bumps on the road are seen as minor setbacks and can be navigated without making major route changes when each bump appears.
Again, look at what Jim McGuinness has done with Donegal. When appointed, McGuinness was quoted as saying “I want our fans to love us again.” In business terms it’s like saying I want our customers and/or shareholders to love us again – and there is generally only one way for this to happen – deliver results.
When McGuinness came in he spoke about a five-year plan, about goals they had set and he has not wavered from that. He’ll constantly talk about the fact that this team is on a journey – and that journey is taking them towards their final destination – the fulfillment of the plan.
Building the team
Having the right people on board is crucial if you want to have any realistic chance of getting to your end-state. Some of the people that you may want to engage may have already experienced past failed attempts to change. To get these people and others on board, the end state will need to be to articulated in a way that it is easy to understand, provides direction and is actionable.
People who understand why will be better motivated and more successful than people who are only informed of what will be done. With all people aligned on the end-state and common goals shared, an energy will be created that ensures the focus is on team success rather than any individual agenda.
When picking the people for your team it is important to remember that people with 100% capability but only 50% commitment may have a negative impact to achieving your overall goal
In the case of McGuiness it is clear that he had the ability to bring a backroom team, selectors and his players together in a fashion that kept them focused on the end state. Like many successful teams in business or in sport having a strong emphasis on responsibility, accountability and loyalty is key.
McGuinness was clear on these requirements and his commitment to these values were tested when one of Donegal’s top players was deemed to have breached this loyalty. His leadership was tested but he stood firm and made a decision based on what he thought was in best interest of the team. At the same time he sent a message that no one individual was above the greater good of the team.
It is clear from Donegal’s performance on the pitch that they have developed an extraordinary cohesiveness, supporting each other in pursuit of a shared objective. This bond can only be achieved by engaging the right people at all levels
Play to your strengths
Knowing your core capabilities and strengths are key to success in any business and using these to build the foundation of your business is key. Many times business failures can be traced back to a time when the business deviated too far too quickly from its core strengths in attempt to grow faster or reach an end goal sooner. It is important to recognise that change is inevitable and innovation is important, but success generally comes when this is done through considered adjustments to the core business plan and not wholesale departure from it.
In the Donegal situation, it is clear that McGuinness knew the strengths and capabilities of his players. He built his plan based on a foundation of building from defence and used each individual component to the best advantage by tailoring his approach to fit the abilities of the team members.
Outside Donegal there was nothing but criticism for the style of play that Donegal adopted. The team was being slaughtered in the media and yet it didn’t distract them from their plan. They didn’t go out the next game completely changed. That’s because they had understood and believed in the long-term plan. In the same way if a business has belief in their product and a proper plan to follow, they shouldn’t be distracted from their end game – their long term goals.
That’s not to say that things were not be measured and tweaked where required, Donegal’s performance against Cork showed that adjustments were made to suit the circumstance on the day.
Excel at the basics
No matter what type of business you are in, it is only with a consistent standard of excellence in quality and service that will allow you to survive and grow. Getting to the required standard of excellence requires hard work, discipline and personal sacrifice. Once you have mastered the basics they will come as second nature and part of the sub conscious and in stressful situations they will become the corner stone of success.
In the Donegal set-up, there can be no denial that this team has worked extremely hard on and off the field on mastering the basics. They have made many personal sacrifices, from training hard in the winter months, sticking rigidly to diet plans and developing self-control and focus which were key ingredients for success on match day. What Donegal has done in such a short space of time has been done with a colossal amount of hard work and ensuring they excel at the basics. The style of play has been evolving but the core principles have remained the same.
Build Confidence
One trait that is evident in all successful business is confidence. When a leader is confident in his team and each team player is confident in themselves and their team-mates then results will be delivered. Confidence does not come overnight. It takes weeks and months of preparation, persistence and patience but to continue on the path of personal sacrifice and hard work people must see that their efforts are producing results. Good leaders will find ways to identify and celebrate small victories.
In Donegal’s case it was clear that confidence has been growing throughout its two-year journey to its first All-Ireland final in twenty years. The winning of a national league title in 2010 may not mean a lot to the major counties but it was an important win for Donegal in the early stage of its journey. Winning the Ulster title in 2011 was the next big confidence builder and repeating this feat in 2012 instilled a greater belief in the team. The championship draw of 2012 could not have been much tougher but the process of continued learning is evident within the Donegal set-up and has allowed the team, the management and support to grow in confidence.
In summary
Donegal’s transformation cannot be put down to any one factor but like business if you install the correct leadership, have a clear vision and plan that everyone understands and is committed too, if you build a team that is complimentary in skills and are willing to work hard towards a shared objectives… then anything is possible.
Businesses in Donegal who take a step back and examine where they are going long term, could enjoy similar success to the Donegal team.
Even if they were to follow just a few of the examples – look to see if you have the right people, focus on the strengths of the people you have, concentrate on the fundamentals and believe in your product – businesses in the county could reap excellent rewards.
** Thanks to Evan Logan for the photos.
Tags: All-Ireland, Business, Donegal, GAA, Jim McGuinness